The Good and Ugly Kinds of Learning Perfectionism
- Written byDonovan NagelDonovan NagelTeacher, translator, polyglotš B.A., Theology, Australian College of Theology, NSWš M.A., Applied Linguistics, University of New England, NSW
Applied Linguistics graduate, teacher and translator. Founder of The Mezzofanti Guild and Talk In Arabic. - Read time5 mins
- Comments4
Rest assured that while the mediaās causing hysteria over North Korea at the moment, people here in South Korea donāt seem to be worried at all. š
First of all, sorry for the lack of frequent updates lately.
Working full-time here in Korea has given me lots of fantastic exposure to the language and helped me make good, native speaker friends but itās also been demanding enough to mean that Iāve had to carefully ration the free time that I get.
My language and fitness targets have been my absolute priority this year, and since the weatherās warmer now Iāve been intentionally spending less time at home and more time out speaking with the Korean locals every chance I get.
Iāve reached the 6 month mark with the Korean language and Iām definitely at a clear intermediate level now which means that spontaneous, fruitful encounters and new friendships have started to become a real regular occurrence, opening up lots of new doors that I previously didnāt have.
My experience with Koreans (particularly in the smaller town that I live in) has shown me that many people here tend to be quite shy about talking to foreigners which I think has a lot to do with them lacking confidence in their own English skills more than anything else. Itās also true that approaching strangers for friendship is rare in Korean culture.
Some East Asian countries can be a tough nut to crack in terms of meeting new people without introduction but itās definitely doable and very rewarding in the end.
This has been challenging but being the stubborn social risk-taker that I am, itās a hurdle that I havenāt backed down from. š
Iām also well aware that itās been 3 months since I uploaded a progress video so Iāll do that and put some recorded chats with friends on my YouTube channel as well for anyone curious in tracking where Iām at.
The snowball effect
The more you comprehend, the more your chances are of learning passively.
Elementary learners often experience the frustration of being around native speakers having a conversation and only being able to pick out a couple of words here and there.
Most of what they hear is meaningless babble.
You simply cannot learn from incomprehensible noise and this is why passive listening as a beginner is pointless. Even though itās good to get familiar with the sounds of the language, itās not an effective use of your time.
But what Iāve noticed time and time again ā especially this time with Korean ā is that when you reach an intermediate level, you really do begin to notice the details of everything thatās going on around you.
Every time youāre in a conversation or within earshot of one at this level, you continually spot patterns, words and expressions that you previously couldnāt notice.
Although this requires you to have good attention to detail, a lot of it also happens effortlessly and unintentionally.
Comprehensible input, whether through reading or listening, is key to learning quickly and effectively, and as an intermediate learner begins to understand much larger amounts of whatās going on around him or her, the input that was previously useless suddenly gains new value.
Stuff that was totally alien a short while ago becomes meaningful ā almost as if it happens overnight.
I think of it as a snowball thatās picking up speed and getting larger the further along it gets.
In the last few weeks, my Korean friends have remarked on what they say is a sharp, rapid improvement in my own level which I put down to the growing momentum of this learning snowball ā pushed by driving perfectionism.
The good and ugly kinds of perfectionism
There are two kinds of perfectionists.
On the one hand, you have the know-it-all, (usually) socially inept types who lambast anyone or anything that dares to step outside the box and challenge the norm.
These are the kinds of vocal grammar nazis you find who just canāt stomach someone elseās unconventional ideas or success.
The people who have this kind of attitude study for ages waiting for the non-existent perfection day to arrive when theyāll finally be ready to start communicating. Theyāre the kind of people who are hesitant to practice openly out of fear of making mistakes and losing face.
Itās a crippling, negative attitude to have.
On the other hand, you have the kind of perfectionism that drives an individual to succeed and to never be satisfied with theyāre at.
I alluded to it here while talking about fossilization:
The key here is to let perfectionism drive you to be on a daily mission to improve ā even with the most rudimentary things.
Iām constantly keeping my ears open to listen to the way native speakers greet each other, the way they ask simple questions, the slang/colloquial expressions they may use in place of standard expressions, accent variations and so on.
I think to myself, āI know how to say X but Iām sure thereās a better, more natural way to say itā so I seek it out, letting that perfectionist ambition drive me to get it right.
As long as you donāt allow perfectionism to stall your progress through fear of making mistakes then itās a powerful thing to be driven by.
This was written by Donovan Nagel.
š Cite article
4 COMMENTS
NO ADVERTISING. Links will be automatically flagged for moderation.
languagewanderer
Nice post. It seems that being on an intermediate level opens the doors for language learnes since they can understand more. Howcer, I wuldnāt say that listening to the conversation in the beginning stage is pontless. Definitely it will all be regsrded as an incomprehensible noise but it entails gettibg used to thr sound of the language. It my view it is good to implelent such listening at the early stages in order to surround yourself with a language.
Marek
I deal with the perfectionism issue to a degree. I believe it does stall my progress. There is a big difference from ābookā learning of a language and how the native speakers speak it. Same thing with English, though. We have āproperā grammar, and then we have the slang we add to it.
hillaryrettig356
Hi, as author of a book about perfectionism (The 7 Secrets of the Prolific), I think youāre right that there are two distinct types of ambitious behavior, and that only one is desirable. Perfectionism is not about having high standards, itās setting unreasonable/unachievable standards and punishing yourself harshly for perceived failures. There are a whole host of other symptoms as well, including grandiosity (thinking things that are hard for other people should be easy for you), expecting easy or effortless success, a focus on product over process, and a focus on external rewards.
Andrew
Good point, Iām glad you put something together about this, Iām sick of people saying you shouldnāt do X type of output (typically speaking) or output in general until youāre at X stage because itāll cause you to develop bad habits that youāll never be able to get rid of and will screw up your abilities in that language forevermore like the linguistic version of HIV or something.
Cheers,
Andrew